The Blues backline puzzle just gets more confusing after the head-scratching selections against Crusaders


The Blues’ penultimate displaying of the season ended with a deflationary thud in Christchurch, a 29-6 loss by the hands of the Crusaders that solely confirmed the worst for the Blues and their followers.

The consequence means that the facet has regressed in a lot of methods nevertheless when you dig slightly deeper, this was primarily a ‘B’ crew despatched out by Leon Macdonald and his employees.

The Crusaders backbone of Codie Taylor, Mitch Drummond, Richie Mo’unga and Will Jordan up towards Kurt Eklund, Jonathan Ruru, Harry Plummer and Stephen Perofeta makes for little comparability. 4 All Blacks versus none.

Video Spacer

Farmland Workhorse of the Week | Aotearoa Rugby Pod

Though the facet misplaced inspirational captain Patrick Tuipulotu to harm previous to the match, there was little sense to the crew that was picked for what was the defining match of the Blues’ season.

A win or, at a minimal, a shedding bonus level was required to make sure the final spherical conflict towards the Chiefs had any bearing on who would make the ultimate.

As a substitute, the Blues have been left with nothing and an anti-climatic ending to a season that held a lot hope after a resurgent 2020 and a quick begin in 2021.

Harry Plummer, who had performed at second 5 almost all season, was thrust into the primary 5 function on the expense of Otere Black.

The identical Otere Black who stored Beauden Barrett at fullback for many of final season and had continued to take strides in 2021 evolving as a rounded playmaker.

In opposition to the Hurricanes in spherical 1 in Wellington, he produced two attempt assists to orchestrate a defeat of his former membership. A cross-field kick to Caleb Clarke and a selfless cross for fullback Stephen Perofeta to walk over lifted the Blues to a complete victory.

Within the Blues’ most full efficiency of the 12 months towards the Highlanders at dwelling, each Black and Perofeta have been instrumental in creating alternatives for the gifted outdoors backs at their disposal and the Blues backline flourished because of this.

At that time within the season, Black was placing his hand up because the second-best 10 within the nation behind Mo’unga and would have been into consideration to enter the All Blacks’ fold.

By the point the Blues’ largest recreation of the season rolled round, he was sitting on the bench as a spectator.

Though Black was compelled onto the sector after fifteen minutes, they hardly impressed confidence of their 10 by opting to start out Plummer.

Coach Leon MacDonald expressed his frustration over how second 5 Taniela Tele’a was faraway from play by the match physician after fifteen minutes, saying that the choice compelled the Blues to desert their recreation plan that that they had practised all week.

It’s laborious to consider that the Blues have been ready to make use of a midfielder who hadn’t began all 12 months because the centre piece of their recreation plan for such an important conflict. By no means thoughts the place final 12 months’s rising star TJ Faiane was, Tele’a was going to form this crucial recreation for the Blues.

The intent of the choice will be construed, they wished a powerful crash ball runner at 12 to win achieve line constantly on the primary part to set-up strikes or switches round a midfield ruck on latter phases with a view to push the Crusaders’ defence by means of the center first after which use that momentum to get them whereas on the again foot.

Having two 10s like Black and Plummer within the line-up wouldn’t permit a direct strategy and one needed to go, but it was the man that they’ve invested almost two years of begins in that received despatched to the pine.

Final 12 months, the Blues have been a facet that kicked closely for territory with Beauden Barrett, Otere Black and Sam Nock their prime three kickers, none of whom have been within the beginning facet on Sunday.

The Blues kicked essentially the most of all of the New Zealand groups in 2020 and had the very best proportion of territorial kicks. Presumably, this compact and easy recreation was to assist their massive pack across the subject and maintain them shifting ahead.

They’ve highly effective, bruising massive males which can be extra famend for punishing defence and powerful set-piece somewhat than deft passing touches and interlinking play with backs so a kick-heavy recreation fits them.

In 2021, the stability of kicking has fallen dramatically away from the choice of territorial development, from 41 per cent of kicks final 12 months to twenty-eight per cent this 12 months.

They used to have three rucks for each kick, now they’re sitting on a ratio of 6:1.

They’re now the facet that kicks the least, by a ways, of the 5 New Zealand groups.

Halfback Nock has not often been sighted in 2021, notching two begins in each wins over the Hurricanes and a bench look within the win towards the Highlanders at dwelling. Within the matches he has performed in, the Blues are 3-0 and the matches with out him taking part in an element, they’re 0-4.

There’s a case to be made that Nock is one of the best half on the roster, with an environment friendly and clear passing movement and a kicking recreation that the Blues themselves relied on closely final 12 months.

Nock can provide a pace of service that the larger man Ruru can’t, but it looks as if Ruru has a mortgage over the beginning place. The place was Nock on Sunday? He’s simply one other long-term funding that the Blues have determined to shelve away this 12 months for causes unknown.

28-year-old Ruru hasn’t proven so much when it comes to nuanced ball-playing and creativity to offer the facet a real playmaker on the base of the ruck, usually at odds with studying his personal teammates.

An errant cross within the first half towards the Crusaders price the Blues an attacking possession and confirmed that he wasn’t fairly on the identical web page as Rieko Ioane making an attempt to take the carry.

With out Patrick Tuipulotu and Josh Goodhue, the Blues have been compelled to depend on younger Sam Darry within the second row, with one other out-of-region recruit Taine Plumtree on the bench. These two are gamers of the longer term with nice potential, maybe not for the right here and now however that was with out selection.

The place they did have selection, the selections have been puzzling. Lacking expertise within the pack, the Blues put All Black starter Ofa Tu’ungafasi on the bench in favour of Nepo Laulala and as an alternative of the barnstorming Akira Ioane, went with the Blake Gibson undertaking at 6.

Gibson has been a growing participant for years and now at 26-years-old, it’s time to query whether or not there’ll ever be the leap to the following degree, significantly with the accidents he has fought again from.

It’s not clear what the Blues wished from their 6, however Ioane proved final 12 months he might take fewer carries and be a defensive monster as a part of a dominant backrow with Papalii and Sotutu. Given an opportunity within the All Blacks, Ioane was the bodily power at worldwide degree that he has promised for years.

When injected into the sport, Ioane was arguably one of the best participant on the sector. If the Blues have been critical about this recreation, why didn’t he begin? Evaluating All Black in his prime versus a growth participant, the choice ought to be apparent.

As if by poetic justice, the primary 4 gamers Will Jordan went previous on path to his first attempt lower than 5 minutes into proceedings have been Blake Gibson, Nepo Laulala, Jonathan Ruru and Harry Plummer, punishing all 4 choices without delay.

Enjoying his guts out, co-captain Dalton Papalii was immense in snatching 4 turnovers and delivering the form of efficiency the Blues wanted throughout the park. Hoskins Sotutu clocked up essentially the most metres of any ahead on the park, carefully adopted by Akira coming off the bench.

The Blues wanted all three on the park to start out with to try to achieve ascendency early. After they fell behind, they have been at all times up towards it.

We’re left with extra questions than solutions following the deflating finish to the Blues hopes in Christchurch. The at the start of which is, what have been they anticipating to occur with a ‘B’ facet towards the defending champions with the season on the road?


Extra Information More News

Mailing Checklist

Signal as much as our mailing checklist for a weekly digest from the broad world of rugby.

Signal Up Now


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *