It’s inconceivable to make all people completely satisfied when discussing the highest quarterbacks in NFL historical past. There’ll at all times be these ranked too excessive, too low, or totally snubbed. The league has drastically modified prior to now decade, not to mention because the daybreak of the Tremendous Bowl period. The Professional Soccer Community Workers performed a gathering of the minds and had some intense discussions to develop the ten names on the listing. However earlier than we start, it’s important to go over precisely how we got here to those selections.
1) Tremendous Bowls usually are not and shouldn’t be the end-all, be-all. Nonetheless, when a person has greater than any singular NFL franchise, it’s tough to argue towards them as the best of all time, even when there was a dialogue about it.
2) A participant’s total résumé is vital, however it was used extra as a tiebreaker than its personal class.
3) Surrounding expertise and scenario mattered to us. If a participant was not requested to be the load-bearer for his or her staff’s nice success, why ought to we elevate them for his or her win-loss file?
4) Bodily expertise and talent as a passer have been weighed the heaviest all through the rating course of.
5) A 100-game pattern dimension was the requirement for consideration.
6) All names ranked performed nearly all of their careers within the Tremendous Bowl period.
Prime quarterbacks in NFL historical past | 1-5
We’ll begin with the ring collector and work our manner down by means of the highest 10.
1) Tom Brady
If Tom Brady’s early struggles in Tampa would have persevered, there might have been an argument to maintain him out of the No. 1 spot within the dialogue for the highest quarterbacks in NFL historical past. Nonetheless, the outdated man turned it round and gained a Tremendous Bowl with out legendary head coach Invoice Belichick.
Sure, Brady’s first three Tremendous Bowl victories have been led by the protection and Adam Vinatieri. However Brady has performed in additional Tremendous Bowls (10) than he has missed whereas absolutely wholesome (8). That’s asinine. It’s tough to examine a profession so lengthy with such constant top-tier staff success, given the parity and one-and-done nature of the game.
Brady’s longevity can also be legendary. No one within the league’s historical past has performed at such a excessive degree at such a complicated age. Brady will presumably finish his profession because the NFL’s all-time chief in passing yards. He additionally will more than likely be the primary quarterback to throw for 600 touchdowns in a profession. Moreover, the previous Patriots’ nice gained an MVP award at 40-years outdated. At age 30, he produced what — for my cash — was probably the most spectacular single passing season of my lifetime, regardless of his data falling to Peyton Manning in his personal historic 2013 season.
2) Aaron Rodgers
Aaron Rodgers is probably the most proficient quarterback of all time (for now). He holds a 4.6 touchdown-to-interception ratio. For reference, that’s twice the speed of Drew Brees, who’s extensively considered probably the most correct passer of all time.
Rodgers’ skill to mix aggression with accountability defending the soccer has blurred the traces on what is feasible as a quarterback. Regardless of not being an amazing athlete, his skill to create out of construction may very properly be why Patrick Mahomes exists.
Rodgers doesn’t have the Tremendous Bowls that many require to put him in such an esteemed place as second on the listing. Simply activate a soccer sport Rodgers is taking part in in. He’s one of the best participant on the sphere for both staff each day out. However as revolutionary as his play is, Rodgers has butted heads with the entrance workplace in Inexperienced Bay and a number of teaching regimes.
If Rodgers weren’t so petty, perhaps he’d have one other ring or two. Then once more, is it the fixed chip on his shoulder that elevated his sport to legendary standing this complete time? The drafting of Jordan Love means that may be the case, as he got here off a number of down seasons (relative to his common play) to win one other league MVP.
3) Peyton Manning
Peyton Manning would get my vote as the best quarterback of all time due to the cerebral manner he went about dominating the place. He’s one of many high quarterbacks in NFL historical past and one of the unathletic quarterbacks we’ve seen.
I additionally consider he was one of the best quarterback of his technology, and his seven All-Professional honors would agree in comparison with Brady’s three. Furthermore, Manning owns a staggering 5 league MVPs, two greater than some other participant in NFL historical past.
But, despite the fact that Manning is 3-2 towards Brady within the playoffs, Brady nonetheless has 5 extra Tremendous Bowls victories than Manning. If that 5 Tremendous Bowl benefit have been its personal participant, it might be tied with Charles Haley for the participant with probably the most Tremendous Bowl titles ever. That’s how insane Brady’s résumé is. And regardless of the overwhelming private accolades Manning possesses, as Herm Edwards most famously stated, “You play to win the sport.”
4) Joe Montana
Many regarded Joe Montana as one of the best quarterback of all time up till Brady. That dialog ended after Tremendous Bowl wins 5 and 6. Montana led the league in completion proportion 5 occasions in his profession. His 1984 season was awe-inspiring because the 18-1 San Francisco 49ers may need been probably the most full NFL staff of all time.
Montana’s accuracy was his calling card, making him one of many high quarterbacks in NFL historical past.
His greatest declare as one of the best quarterback of all time was his unbelievable performances as a playoff quarterback. His run of playoff performances from 1988-1990 was legendary, as he posted an 11:1 TD/INT ratio. Yards aren’t essentially an excellent stat to go by, however Montana raised his yards output from 211.2 yards per sport within the common season to 251 within the playoffs.
I nearly forgot to say he went undefeated in Tremendous Bowls (4-0). There’s a purpose he acquired the nickname “Joe Cool.”
5) Dan Marino
Dan Marino’s 1984 marketing campaign is probably the most ridiculous era-adjusted season ever. Marino was the primary 5,000-yard passer, and he threw 48 touchdowns, beating the earlier file by 12.
No one aside from Marino had a 40-touchdown season till Kurt Warner in 1999. His 48-touchdown file stood till Peyton Manning broke it in 2004. The following 5,000-yard passing season was Drew Brees in 2008. That alone may make him one of many high quarterbacks in NFL historical past.
Marino was the final of the six quarterbacks drafted within the first spherical of the 1983 NFL Draft. That draft supplied probably the greatest quarterback courses of all time with Corridor of Famers John Elway and Jim Kelly. Marino’s fast launch and velocity made the Dolphins quarterback extensively thought-about probably the most proficient of his technology. The numbers don’t lie.