I for one don’t welcome our crappy new robot umpire masters


Juuuuust a bit outside.

Juuuuust a bit exterior.
Screenshot: Blue Ridge 11

Do you keep in mind the half in Iron Man 2 the place Tony Stark was in court docket and the US authorities was primarily making an attempt to take the Iron Man expertise for themselves and their argument was that different nations have been growing the identical expertise, then Stark hacked the screens and confirmed a video of Justin Hammer’s crew testing out a prototype that twisted and failed and seemed prefer it nearly killed the particular person inside it? That’s mainly the place we’re at with calling balls and strikes, besides there’s no Iron Man — only a bunch of actually horrible, flawed prototypes, like Ángel Hernández.

Umpires lacking calls will not be a brand new factor. It’s all the time been part of this sport, and purists will say, “Nicely, so long as it’s constant, it’s okay.” However, no, it completely will not be. The human component of baseball is okay and dandy, however when expertise continues to advance, and we’ve an overlay of the strike zone on our screens at residence that may inform us in actual time whether or not a pitch was a strike or a ball, it’s time that we discover a answer to get the decision proper.

Simply final week, Tampa Bay Rays and MLB prime prospect Wander Franco, who made his Main League debut on June 22, was on the receiving finish of some horrible strike zone administration by umpire Hunter Wendelstedt.

These pitches are nearly within the opposing batter’s field. Not solely that, they’re not even breaking pitches. How do you name a straight fastball that’s three ball-widths off the plate a strike? And extra importantly, how do you do it a number of instances?

It didn’t go effectively for umpire Brian O’Nora final night time both. He single handedly had 9 of the ten worst calls of the day, and solely had a 83.5% accuracy score.

Conditions like this depart batters guessing in a sport the place pitchers are already extra instances than not.

So, in an effort to repair the horrible officiating of Main League umpires and to automate the method, the Atlantic League has begun exploring automated strike zones. At present setting apart the truth that the system, in and of itself, has some flaws and questions in regards to the affect it might have on the sport, final night time demonstrated simply how far-off we’re from having an correct automated strike zone.

The pitch was to this point low and away that the catcher didn’t even try to border it. The commentators, who have been discussing one other subject, interjected with a fast “ball two, it’s exterior,” then went again to their dialog. The catcher lofts it again in the direction of the mound, and everybody was transferring on to what ought to have been a 2-2 depend.

Then the umpire rings up the batter, who seems to be former large leaguer Jordan Pacheco of the Lexington Legends (see his tweet above) who drops the bat and places his fingers on his knees in disbelief. The catcher seems up at him as if to say, “Yeah, uhh, sorry man.” A very good twenty seconds later, the commentators understand that it was known as for a strike.

“Oh, that went down as strike three!”

“Let It Go,” from the film Frozen, performed over the sound system, in a very savage show of pettiness.

Baseball is in a time the place hits are down, strikeouts are up, umpires are innately flawed, and there’s no correct substitute in sight. However hey, America’s Pastime, amirite?


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *