More Penguins Armchair GMing – Pittsburgh Penguins – PenguinPoop Blog


It is a nice time of 12 months for hockey followers. In case your crew was the one crew that simply gained Lord Stanley’s Cup you might be out reveling in your crew’s victory. In case your crew was one of many 30 different additionally rans, there’s optimism that with the best low season strikes your crew can now place itself for that Cup win; talks and rumors abound.

Sadly, subsequent July, as soon as once more, just one crew and their followers will likely be celebrating. The remainder will as soon as once more be spinning their wheels in useless anticipation.

Luck can typically issue right into a crew’s enchancment, however a crew could make its personal luck by taking a chilly, onerous, essential take a look at itself, divorcing itself of ego and preconceived notions. The perfect and first place to begin is to ask the place did the crew fail? And that’s what has me anxious. With all of the chatter and rumors, one might simply suppose nobody was paying shut consideration. Granted, below Ron Hextall, there’s little substantive objects popping up, primarily speaking heads making an attempt to promote promoting house, however every little thing thus far factors to writers and probably even Hextall greedy at low hanging fruit, relatively than an goal evaluation of the crew’s third consecutive 1st spherical exit.

Take a look at all of the names being tossed round as commerce targets; first it was Zack Kassian, later The Hockey Writers advised Matthew Tkachuk, extra not too long ago after Invoice Guerin’s Minnesota Wild buyouts, Zach Parise. Even our personal Rick Buker wrote in regards to the thought of making an attempt to get Ryan Reaves again. Now, I simply learn a fast headline suggesting that our Pittsburgh Penguins have critical curiosity in Zach Hyman.

What do all these gamers have in frequent?

No, not all of them are named Zach or a variation there of.

They’re all forwards.

Cease it already!!! Our Favourite Flightless Fowl the place not dumped out of the playoffs as a result of they didn’t have the fireplace energy to determine a lead! That they had leads in each Sport 5 and Sport 6 for goodness sake, however they may not defend these leads.

If you’d like and might discover a strategy to get Hyman, Tkachuk, Parise, and or for that matter, Connor McDavid, Leon Drasaitl, Auston Matthews, and Nikita Kucherov, within the phrases of Rocky Balboa “Go for it!” however first exit and repair the groups protection. A crew can rating all of the Objectives (G) it needs, and it gained’t matter if the opposite crew scores extra.

The underside line to the Black and Gold’s early tee-times centered on 3 defensive gaffes. Kris Letang pinching with a 1 G lead in sport 5, leaving a ahead, Jake Guentzel to play protection. In Double Time beyond regulation (2 OT) of the identical sport, Cody Ceci pinching all the best way all the way down to the objective leaving a hobbled left-handed Evgeni Malkin to cowl his proper level. After which Letang, once more, this time with the lead in sport 6, playing and making an attempt to maintain the play alive and pinching down the wall, leaving the Captain Sidney Crosby to attempt to race again and canopy for the ersatz defenseman.

The New York Islanders didn’t overwhelm our Boys of Winter with offense. When Hextall went out and stole Jeff Carter from the Los Angeles Kings, the middle depth arguably put our hometown heroes within the high 5 within the league in ahead depth. No on the contrary, the Islanders beat our Penguins by being way more disciplined defensively.

I don’t care if you wish to blame Letang and Ceci or if you wish to blame their Coaches, Mike Sullivan and Todd Reirden. I’ll take heed to your arguments. In reality, I’ll assist you argue both level. Nonetheless, Hextall begin right here fixing the protection.

And no Mike, whereas I agree that forwards do have to take their very own portion of accountability in crew protection, inherent to the time period defenseman is protection first. Neither Letang nor Ceci had any enterprise leaping up on these performs and dropping that collection for the crew. If the crew was dropping and the protection jumped up then I might agree with you, the forwards wanted to help their defensemen. However that was not the case right here.

So far as the crew’s defensive gamers are involved, for all I care, dump all of them and begin from scratch.

Marcus Pettersson is method overpaid for what he has introduced for the final 2 seasons. He was given his elevate far too early in his profession.

Cody Ceci was enough that’s all. You don’t re-sign him for way more than what he was already getting.

Mike Matheson performed higher than I anticipated however Ceci performed higher and much cheaper. Moreover, there’s some proof to recommend that Ceci was the important thing to Matheson’s success, so if Ceci goes, Matheson might comply with Pettersson and John Marino in having an honest 1st season within the black-and-gold, thrilling the followers solely to disappoint them the next season. Truthfully, I might commerce away all different choices to make Matheson the almost definitely choose of the Seattle Kraken.

John Marino, like Pettersson was given a big, unearned elevate after nothing greater than 1-promising season solely to fall in need of fulfilling expectations the subsequent season. Nonetheless, in Marino’s case, though I wouldn’t be upset over a commerce that cleared his $4+ million from the books, I might relatively maintain him and see what this season brings. Marino could have been a sufferer poor teaching. I’m not sorry. You don’t ask your youngest defenseman to play his off-side, nor do you attempt to pair him with a associate that’s an excessive defensive legal responsibility after which flip round and blame the child you arrange for failure.

Brian Dumoulin is the very best defenseman on the roster, however let’s face it, that doesn’t essentially imply a lot. He actually has little to no competitors.

Kris Letang continues to be a great offensive participant however has little defensive acumen. Outdoors of offensive upside, the one different optimistic about Letang is that he’s lastly on the finish of his contract and if sentimentality prevails and he stays it in all probability will likely be for a worth extra in keeping with his incapability to defend.

Pierre-Olivier Joseph has proven some abilities. Sadly, he’s extraordinarily gentle for his dimension and his talent set is a cookie-cutter talent set to each different defenseman on the crew. If he’s used as a sweetener in a deal for a extra essential prize, then so be it.


Nonetheless, if you wish to argue that it wasn’t the gamers as a lot because the teaching, I’m proper there with you. Reality, Sidney Crosby ended the season 129th amongst forwards and 58th amongst facilities with 200 or extra 5-on-5 minutes performed, in Factors/60 minutes. Fifty-eighth amongst facilities places him down virtually into third line territory. How can this be? Did he lose that a lot of his talent?

Clearly no! The Captain will need to have had a tough time scoring when he was at all times making an attempt to cowl up for wandering defensemen.

The issue is systemic. Sullivan and Reirden try to drive the offense by means of the protection. They need to suppose they’ve the 1992 – 93 Washington Capitals’ protection. That protection had 3 gamers rating greater than 20 Gs, Kevin Hatcher (35), Al Iafrate (25), and Sylvain Cote (21) and had 4 gamers with greater than 40 factors, Hatcher (79), Iafrate (66), Cote (50), and Calle Johansson (45).

The most important 2 issues right here is; A. that crew didn’t win the Cup and misplaced to the Islanders within the 1st spherical as nicely, and; B. the one defenseman on the Penguins’ roster that may very well be put in the identical breath as Hatcher, Iafrate, Cote, and Johansson, is Letang. Finish of story.

Severely Sullivan and Reirden, do you actually need Pettersson carrying the puck, not Crosby?

In the event you actually wish to emulate that Capitals crew that didn’t get any farther than 1st spherical, then dump Matheson, Dumoulin, Ceci, Pettersson, and Marino and exit and get Cale Makar, Tyson Barrie, Jack Carlson, Adam Fox, and Jeff Petry to affix Letang, or begin teaching the crew you do have and never the crew you want you had.

Now, Mr. Hextall, you’ll be able to exit and get Hyman or every other ahead you need.


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *