Amidst their desperation to discover a new quarterback, the Panthers accomplished a commerce Monday that brings former No. 3 total decide Sam Darnold to Carolina in change for a 2021 sixth spherical decide, a 2022 second spherical decide, and a 2022 fourth spherical decide. At first look it’s the type of deal worthy of ridicule. However is there one thing extra to the commerce than meets the attention?
The Panthers did a horrible job of hiding their needs to discover a new quarterback. Publicly the staff was touting the concept that Teddy Bridgewater was “their man,” however with each quarterback transfer this offseason got here information the Panthers have been speaking to groups as properly. They have been near a deal for Matthew Stafford, till the Rams provided extra. They have been all for Carson Wentz, till a deal was finalized with Indianapolis. The looming chance of creating a mammoth commerce for Deshaun Watson was nonetheless being touted as just lately as a month in the past, however rapidly silenced throughout wide-ranging sexual assault and harassment allegations.
This left Carolina in a bizarre spot. It is a staff in determined want of a quarterback to begin implementing the offensive rebuild coach Matt Rhule and co. began a yr in the past, nevertheless it was more and more wanting like there wasn’t an possibility. The Panthers have been confronted with the fact that they could both want to succeed in for a second-tier quarterback within the draft, or commerce the farm in hopes of shifting as much as get somebody they appreciated. Ultimately this third selection offered itself, and it might have simply protected the Panthers … from themselves.
Up so far each potential QB state of affairs for Carolina was loathsome. Had they landed Stafford it could have been the height of desperation, and an incongruous transfer for a staff constructing round youth. Any state of affairs within the draft centered on shifting up would have mortgaged the staff’s future for years to come back. Resigning themselves to begin Bridgewater once more in 2021 with out competitors was the equal of punting on the season.
The circuitous route Carolina took to buying and selling for Sam Darnold is the type of transfer that can both be worthy of the mockery it’s at the moment being met with, or wind up being genius — and there’s compelling causes for each situations.
Darnold has proven flashes
The thought of Darnold being a “bust” is labored at finest. The actual fact is, there have been loads of video games and moments the place there have been flashes of the participant folks hoped he can be popping out of USC.
Have a look at Week 1 of the 2019 season, for instance. Regardless of having few weapons, and dealing with a brutal Payments’ protection, Darnold pushed Buffalo to the wire, dropping 17-16 in a sport the place he accomplished over 68 % of his passes and completed with a 84.9 score.
That very same yr, only a few weeks later, Darnold returned from his meme-worthy absence on account of mononucleosis, and threw for over 300 yards towards the Cowboys. Not solely was this a breakout efficiency, however he accomplished over 70 % of his passes and completed with a 113.8 score.
There was inconsistency all through the season to make sure, however Darnold nonetheless managed to throw for over 3,000 yards in 13 video games. This was with an offensive line that allowed him to be sacked 33 occasions on the yr.
There’s familiarity in Carolina
Buying and selling for Darnold isn’t solely out of left discipline for the Panthers, and there’s a standard thread right here: Large receiver Robby Anderson. Anderson labored for 2 years with Darnold on the Jets earlier than leaving for Carolina, and through his time in New York he was the younger QB’s favourite goal. Understand that one of many greatest causes Matt Rhule signed Anderson was familiarity, teaching the receiver at Temple.
So there’s a logical by line right here the place Rhule would have consulted together with his 1,000 yard receiver about the way it was to play with Darnold, and whether or not there’s potential there. It’s the type of endorsement that might have been sufficient to push the Panthers to make a deal.
All the time financial institution on Adam Gase’s ineptitude
Even in case you’re not offered on Darnold the participant, it’s unimaginable to disclaim that he entered the league within the worst scenario of any rookie quarterback — due to Adam Gase. A person who will go down in NFL infamy for his lack of ability as a coach, there’s already a transparent litmus check of Gase being full inept on the subject of evaluating and using quarterbacks.
Usually I’d say it’s unfair to pin all of a quarterback’s failings on a head coach, however I’ll gladly make an exception for Adam Gase. As PFF mentions above, Ryan Tannehill appeared like he was destined to be a journeyman backup earlier than being bounced out of the league till he left Miami, obtained away from Gase, and rapidly grew to become among the finest quarterbacks within the NFL.
Now, that’s a fairly distinctive scenario, but when there’s ever a time to wager on a turnaround, this is likely to be the one. We have now a transparent, analogous case of a Gase quarterback leaving for one more staff, and instantly turning into the participant hoped they may after being considered a bust.
It’s not simply the schemes Gase applied that failed, however his utter lack of ability to place expertise round younger quarterbacks. Throughout his tenure in Miami the most effective receiver Tannehill had was Jarvis Landry, who was allowed to stroll and changed with … a 33-year-old Danny Amendola.
Equally, Darnold’s finest receiver throughout his time in New York was Robby Anderson, who was additionally allowed to stroll in free company and changed with … a 33-year-old Chris Hogan.
Darnold has by no means had a greater probability to indicate he belongs
The 23-year-old is getting a lot greater than a change of surroundings. Not solely is he being reunited with the most effective receiver he had on the Jets, but additionally one other 1,000 yard receiver in D.J. Moore, Christian McCaffery at operating again who can catch outlet passes, in addition to David Moore and Dan Arnold, two big-play move catchers signed in free company.
Most significantly he’ll get to work with Joe Brady, the offensive coordinator who took Joe Burrow and turned him right into a Heisman winner, and stellar rookie earlier than he was misplaced to damage. Now, for the primary time in his profession, Darnold has an precise help construction round him that can enable him to indicate what he’s obtained.
Does this imply the Jets made a mistake by buying and selling Darnold?
Hell no. Completely not. Shopping for into the concept Darnold is a legend within the making is a enjoyable chance, however the actuality if that there’s nothing he confirmed in New York that justifies passing on a quarterback with the No. 2 decide. particularly if there’s somebody new coach Robert Saleh believes in. By all accounts that appears to be Zach Wilson, and the staff is ready to construct round him.
Ultimately New York needed to transfer on, whether or not Darnold was a sufferer or circumstance or not — and so they managed to get some picks in addition. This can assist with their rebuilding efforts shifting ahead.
And what concerning the Panthers?
One of the best a part of this commerce is that Carolina pivoted from the potential of taking a significant danger within the draft, to a minor one through commerce. Even when Darnold is horrible, they didn’t hand over a lot to take the chance. Carolina will discover itself again within the high 10 once more subsequent yr, this time with a greater probability of touchdown a high quarterback.
For now although, they’re going to present Darnold a shot, and it’s going to be fascinating to see the way it pans out.